Erica R. Connecticut

Apple Vs FBI

Apple and the FBI must work together in order to prevent future terrorism attacks.

Dear Future President,

With the current influx of terrorism in our nation, it is critical that we do all that we can to prevent it before it starts. In order to prevent attacks it is necessary that we learn from the past. Understanding who is involved and effectively monitoring them is the best way to ensure that attacks do not occur.

In the case of the shooter from the San Bernardino attacks, the FBI seeked Apple’s assistance in unlocking the shooter’s, Syed Farook’s, iPhone. Apple claimed that this request was “chilling” and that this step would threaten the security of their customers. Although I can understand where Apple is coming from concerning the freedom and rights that the Constitution provides, I believe that under certain circumstances people can lose these rights.

After Syed Farook killed 14 Americans in his attack, I strongly believe that no one, including Apple, should be worried about protecting this man’s rights. Information could be accessed from his phone that could potentially uncover accomplices and other intel. This would allow the government to monitor the people that this terrorist may have been communicating with and other plans that may have been in progress.

There are a very limited number of ways to prevent terrorism, but unlocking the iPhone and taking a look at the past could certainly stop terrorism before the plans have a chance to be carried out. U.S. citizens may have concerns regarding the privacy of their Apple devices, however, the FBI would only look to Apple in desperate times. The majority of Americans do not have to worry about the FBI accessing their phones. In my opinion if you have nothing to hide then why would you be concerned with your phone being accessed if it could potentially save lives?

Farook gave up his rights when he decided to execute an attack, taking 14 innocent lives. The U.S. should not be obligated to protect his privacy rights when it could prevent future attacks. 

Thank you,

Erica R

Lewis S. Mills High School

Advanced Composition

Mrs. Mandel's Advanced Composition students write about what's meaningful to them, across disciplines, genres, and domains.

All letters from this group →